Minneapolis St. Paul News, Weather, Traffic, Sports | Minneapolis, Minnesota | kare11.com

Couple wins cafe, changes the flavor of small town dining

A chance to reclaim a dream seemingly lost in the Great Recession.
Credit: Devin Krinke, KARE
Elizabeth and Seth Lintelman, owners of the Cup N' Saucer Cafe

SHERBURN, Minn. — In Sherburn, Minnesota the first light of day comes from the Cup N' Saucer Café.

“It's our morning stop, 6:30 morning stop,” Brian Steen says.

Steen sits among the other farmers and retirees at a corner table by the café’s front window. 

Their table.

Credit: Boyd Huppert, KARE
Farmers and retirees occupy the window seat before sunrise at the Cup N' Saucer

As coffee is poured, the conversation shifts easily from sports, to the state of the fall harvest, to the day’s news – within the same walls the café’s owners, Seth and Elizabeth Lintelman, have spent the past few years making news of their own.

“We’re not your average small-town café,” Elizabeth says.

The story is, by now, the stuff of local legend, documented in newspaper clippings neatly arranged on the café’s walls.

“When we first won, I told people, ‘I won a restaurant in an essay contest,’” Elizabeth says, smiling.  

“And they said, ‘You want a restaurant?’” 

“’No, I won a restaurant,’” Elizabeth continues with emphasis. 

The backstory is almost as sweet as the story that’s followed.

For the better part of six decades, the Cup N' Saucer operated among several bustling Sherburn cafés.  

Credit: Elizabeth Lintelman
Workers and customers at the Cup N' Saucer in its early days

When it closed nine years ago, “The Cup” was the last to go.

“They all disappeared, people retired, nobody else went in,” Cup regular, Dennis Scheff says.

Population migration from farm to big city has not been kind to downtown Sherburn. 

Credit: Devin Krinke, KARE
Sherburn, Minnesota is a community of 1100 people located in Martin County

Peeling paint on empty storefronts tells a tale familiar in rural Minnesota.

Yet, 150 miles away - on a similar timeline - in the Twin Cities, the fortunes of newlyweds Elizabeth and Seth were also crumbling.  

“We bought our home in Crystal when we were very young and probably the worst time you could buy a house,” Elizabeth says. “I lost my job in 2009 and that was right about the time we were close to $100,000 upside down on our mortgage.”

In one swoop Elizabeth and Seth lost their home and their dream.

“There was no way we could start a restaurant, no one would give us a loan to buy a house, nevertheless start a business,” Elizabeth says.

Which brings us 150 miles back to the restaurant-desert Sherburn had become.

For two years the Cup N’ Saucer sat empty, Sherburn deprived of its favorite gathering place.

Then, civic-minded local philanthropists Gene and Carmen Scheppman reopened The Cup with a crazy plan. They would bring the café back to life, then give it away.

It didn’t take long for the news to reach Elizabeth in the Twin Cities. “I got a text from my mother-in-law saying there's an essay contest to win a restaurant in Sherburn,” she says.  

This could be it, Elizabeth thought. Their chance to reclaim a dream seemingly lost in the Great Recession.

Credit: Devin Krinke, KARE
Elizabeth and Seth Lintelman at work in the Cup N' Saucer kitchen

In her essay, Elizabeth wrote of family, community and the importance of protecting beloved institutions like a certain main street cafe.

She won.

The Cup N' Saucer was theirs - though Sherburn had yet to learn the change that was about to greet their palates.

Seth, the son of a Martin County hog farmer, had graduated culinary school and already had more than a decade under his chef's cap at Lake Minnetonka's elegant Lafayette Club.

Canned corn and iceberg lettuce would no longer cut it at the Cup.

During a recent lunch rush, Seth popped open the oven door to sprinkle shallots on baked carrots.

Credit: Boyd Huppert, KARE
The Cup N' Saucer offers locally sources vegetables, like these baked carrots

Nearby, Elizabeth ladled parsnip bisque, before adding peppadew peppers and Castelvetrano olives to a handmade lunch salad.

Look as hard as you want, there’s not a french fry to be found. The Cup N’ Saucer doesn’t even own a deep fryer.

What could be found, in the early days, was skeptics.

The Lintelmans can’t forget the anonymous, handwritten letter they received shortly after taking ownership of the café.

“The style of food you want to do that’s from The Cities does not work down here,” they were informed.

The writer claimed to have recently visited, “You’re charging too much money,” Seth recalls the critical customer writing. “We couldn’t find anything that we could eat or wanted to eat or even knew what it was.”


“Basically, saying we were crazy for doing what we were doing,” Seth says. “We might as well just pack up and go now because no one’s going to support us.”

One-time skeptics are now lucky to find a seat.

Credit: Boyd Huppert, KARE
Full house for breakfast at the Cup N' Saucer

On a recent Wednesday, the café was bustling for breakfast and lunch.

“You should see it on a Saturday,” Elizabeth says. “We have people standing outside waiting for tables.”

Even Seth was skeptical when his old boss at Lafayette Club suggested he try a Saturday evening tasting menu at the Cup N’ Saucer.   

“I was pretty sure we were going to have a hard time filling it,” Seth says.

He was wrong.

At $80 per person, the monthly five-course tasting menu currently has a waiting list of two-and-a-half years.

Next available seat: summer of 2022.

“It's just unreal,” Steen says. “Around here I didn't think there was a market for it.”

Elizabeth and Seth, meantime, have the privilege of raising daughters 2-year-old Parker and 7-year-old Addison in the family’s new home across a gravel driveway from Seth’s parents.

Credit: Devin Krinke, KARE
Addison Lintelman, 7, having breakfast at the Cup N' Saucer with her mom and grandparents.

Addison helps her grandpa pick from his garden the vegetables her parents serve at the café.

Other area farmers also contribute to The Cup's symphony of locally-sourced flavors.

“I know that I can cook, and I know I can bring out enough flavor and things to get people’s mindsets to change,” Seth says.  

“We’ve come a long way, a very long way,” the Cup N’ Saucer’s chef and owner continues. “And I think the people, the community of Martin County and surrounding counties, I think they’ve come a long way with us.”

By lunch time, Lonna Larson and her friends occupy the round table surrendered by early-risers and mid-morning dice players.

Credit: Devin Krinke, KARE
The mid-morning dice group meets at the Cup N' Saucer

“I can’t even pronounce half the stuff,” Lonna says of The Cup’s menu, “but they’ll explain it to me if I ask.”

The women at the table gives thumbs up to the parsnip bisque and other soups-of-the day not normally found in small town cafés.

“I don’t think they’ve ever had chicken noodle or chili,” Lonna laughs.

Lonna, who says she stops by the Cup N’ Saucer two or three times a week, says she doesn’t miss the french fries. “You don’t even want to think of anything greasy in here, everything is always fresh and healthy,” she says.

Six years ago, the Seth and Elizabeth wrote an essay and rolled the dice.

Now, the proof is in the bread pudding. The Lintelmans and Sherburn both came up winners.

MORE: Senior dorm: college students move into assisted living home

MORE: Teen's obsession with car lots brings unexpected gift

MORE: Farmer turns his combine into candy dispenser

Check out more Land of 10,000 Stories below on our YouTube channel.